Wos review template Clarivate word

Web of Science Academy Peer Review Report Template for Co-reviewing with a Mentor
Your name: Toshpulat Nazarov	Mentor’s name: Karen Berger
Manuscript/paper title: Performing the Bounds of Responsibility	DOI (if published):  https://doi.org/10.3390/h10040112 - 15 Oct 2021    
Journal: Humanities	Review due date: 18.11.2021

Summary statement of the article and its findings in your own words	This paper investigates border-making dynamics in the two political arenas where my subjectivity is most acutely implicated across time—the Jewish Holocaust (as an intergenerational victim) and the Aboriginal genocide (as an unwitting beneficiary). 
Major strengths of the article and what impact it might have in your field	Albeit that there are many differences between the drivers of antisemitism and racism against Indigenous Australians, I investigate both of these racist structures through the lens of border-thinking as theorised by Walter Mignolo as a method of decolonisation (2006).      
Specific areas of improvement needed in the article before it can be published	Major points (needs for clarification, re-analysis, re-writes and/or additional information and suggestions which would improve the article): 1. True 2. False 3. True       Minor points (inconsistencies, major typos) 1. True 2. False 3. True      
Confidential comments to the editor (include your recommendation for publication here)	     

© 2021 Clarivate