Wos review template Clarivate word

Web of Science Academy Peer Review Report Template for Co-reviewing with a Mentor
Your name: Usanov Ulug'bek Nurulla o'g'li	Mentor’s name: Daniel Paton 
Manuscript/paper title:  Climatic and Biological Factors Related with Goat Grazing Management in the Arid Grassland of the Coquimbo Region (Northern Chile)	DOI (if published): https://doi.org/10.3390/ecologies2040020 
Journal: Ecologies https://www.mdpi.com/2673-4133/2/4/20 	Review due date: 30.04.2022 year

Summary statement of the article and its findings in your own words	This article provides information on climate and biological factors associated with goat rearing management in arid grasslands of the Coquimbo region. In this data, he experimented with how to artificially increase rainfall in the region, resulting in increased drought resistance of the region’s plants, and recommended feeding goats with a delayed grazing type. 
Major strengths of the article and what impact it might have in your field	In this paper, Alloxton reported that endemic and native species showed significant changes for seasonal and annual precipitation, in contrast, the feeding system only affected the dominance and biomass of native and endemic species. Delayed feeding is the only management system that increases overall biomass productivity, especially in the best species of forage plants. Exceptions have had a positive effect on endangered species, which are most vulnerable to overgrazing of goats. This idea can simultaneously increase the productivity of forage hay, conservation of pastures and conservation of resources related to hunting, wildlife tourism 
Specific areas of improvement needed in the article before it can be published	Major points (needs for clarification, re-analysis, re-writes and/or additional information and suggestions which would improve the article): 1. This article provides good recommendations and has been put into practice on how to adapt goats to drought conditions, increase their viability and increase their level of development. 2.  In addition, information is provided on h ow to increase the long-term drought tolerance and plant biomass of desert plants, which are a source of food for goats. 3.     Minor points (inconsistencies, major typos) 1.   2.   3.    
Confidential comments to the editor (include your recommendation for publication here)	There is no conflict of interest here we are not familiar with the author.

© 2021 Clarivate