Ugi 131 – Regional Economics of Turkey tobb etü Tashkent 2021-2022 Spring Semester Take Home Assignment

UGI 131 – Regional Economics of Turkey
TOBB ETÜ Tashkent - 2021-2022 Spring Semester
Take Home Assignment
Name: Alisher UMAROV 6 March 2022
Student Number / ID Number: 217125001

Assignment 4

Kazakhstan  Governance indicators
Voice and Accountability in Kazakhstan VS Central Asia(CA) countries
My selected country is Kazakhstan, and I interested in comparison with Central Asia countries. We discussed about best and worst performers in our last lecture, and that is why I choose to compare my selected country with Central Asia countries in terms of some indicators.
So, as we can see in the line graph Central Asia countries perform almost the same over the years (1996-2020) in terms of Voice and Accountability indicator. In 2004, I think there were some kind of political changes in all (CA) countries, because in that year we can see huge increase in the graph. Kazakhstan, I can say perform better than other CA countries, but overall it is not.
Absence of Violence/Terrorism  Central Asia countries
Overall, Kazakhstan perform better than other CA countries in terms of Absence of Violence/Terrorism. There is kind of fluctuation over the years (1996-2020) in Kazakhstan trend line, and since 2008 it was decreasing.





In the next figure – single line, we can see some highest points over the years.



Turkey Government Effectiveness In this graph, we can see Kazakhstan trend line increased significantly over the years (1996-2020).



Regulatory Quality
In that case, there was dramatic decrease from 1996 to 2002, but then it increased dramatically over the years (2002-2020).
Rule of Law
So, I can say Kazakhstan is kind of worst performer in that case, even there was huge increase over the years (1996-2020).

Control of Corruption
In that case I interested in comparison of Central Asia countries again;), so Kazakhstan is better perform over the years (1996-2020).

Kazakhstan
Governance Indicators - snapshot
Overall, we can say there are increases in all Governance indicator except Voice and Accountability.
s ource: World Bank, https://info.worldbank.org/governance/wgi/ [for all graphs]
Kazakhstan
Logistic Performance Index - Snapshot
Source: Source: World Bank, https://lpi.worldbank.org/about

Kazakhstan

Research & Development Expenditures
Source: https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/GB.XPD.RSDV.GD.ZS?end=2018&locations=KZ&start=2000
Kazakhstan
Domestic Credit to Private Sector

Source: https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/FS.AST.PRVT.GD.ZS?locations=KZ