constituted by simply what gives pleasure and what avoids pain.
Susie likes
chocolate. She is afraid of dogs. She enjoys coloring. She is often mean to her
brother. This is the extent of Susie’s identity because her Thinking Brain has
not yet developed enough meaning to create coherent stories for her. It’s only
when she’s old enough to ask what the pleasure is
for, what the pain is
for,
that she can develop some meaningful narratives for herself,
and establish
identity.
The knowledge of pleasure and pain is still there in adolescence. It’s just
that pleasure and pain no longer dictate most decision making.
17
They are no
longer the basis of our values. Older children weigh their personal feelings
against their understanding of rules, trade-offs, and the social order around
them to plan and make decisions.
This gives them larger, sturdier identities.
18
The adolescent does the same stumbling around the young child does in
learning what is pleasurable and what is painful, except the adolescent
stumbles around by trying on different social rules and roles. If I wear this,
will it make me cool? If I talk like that, will it make people like me? If I
pretend
to enjoy this music, will I be popular?
19
This is an improvement, but there’s still a weakness in this adolescent
approach to life. Everything is seen as a trade-off. Adolescents approach life
as an endless series of bargains: I will do what my boss says so I can get
money. I will call my mother so I don’t get yelled at. I will do my homework
so I don’t fuck up my future. I will lie and pretend to be nice so I don’t have
to deal with conflict.
Nothing is done for its own sake. Everything is
a calculated transaction,
usually made out of fear of the negative repercussions. Everything is a
means
to some pleasurable end.
20
The problem with adolescent values is that if you hold them, you never
actually stand for something outside yourself. You are still at heart a child,
albeit a cleverer and much more sophisticated child. Everything still revolves
around maximizing
pleasure and minimizing pain, it’s just that the adolescent
is savvy enough to think a few moves ahead to get there.
In the end, adolescent values are self-defeating. You can’t live your entire
life this way, otherwise you’re never actually living your own life. You’re
merely living out an aggregation of the desires of the people around you.
To become an emotionally healthy individual, you must break out of this
constant
bargaining, endlessly treating everyone as a means to some
pleasurable end, and come to understand even higher and more abstract
guiding principles.