568 Chapter
16
Treatment of Psychological Disorders
Psychosurgery
If ECT strikes you as a questionable procedure, the use of
psychosurgery —brain
surgery in which the object is to reduce symptoms of mental disorder—probably
appears even more dubious. A technique used only rarely today, psychosurgery was
introduced as a “treatment of last resort” in the 1930s.
The
initial form of psychosurgery, a
prefrontal lobotomy, consisted of surgically
destroying or removing parts of a patient’s frontal lobes, which surgeons thought
controlled emotionality. In the 1930s and 1940s, surgeons performed the procedure
on thousands of patients often with little precision. For example, in one common
technique, a surgeon literally would jab an ice pick under a patient’s eyeball and
swivel it back and forth (El-Hai, 2005; Ogren & Sandlund, 2007).
Psychosurgery often did improve a patient’s behavior—but
not without drastic
side effects. Along with remission of the symptoms of the mental disorder, patients
sometimes experienced personality changes and became bland, colorless, and unemo-
tional. In other cases, patients became aggressive and unable to control their impulses.
In the worst cases, treatment resulted in the patient’s death.
With the introduction of effective drug treatments—and
the obvious ethical ques-
tions regarding the appropriateness of forever altering someone’s personality—
psychosurgery became nearly obsolete. However, it is still used in very rare cases
when all other procedures have failed and the patient’s behavior presents a high risk
to the patient and others. For example, surgeons sometimes use a more precise form
of psychosurgery called a
cingulotomy in rare cases of obsessive-compulsive disorder
in which they destroy tissue in the
anterior cignulate area of the brain. In another
technique,
gamma knife surgery, beams of radiation are used to destroy areas of the
brain related to obsessive-compulsive disorder (Shah et al., 2008; Carey, 2009c; Lopes
et al, 2009; Wilkinson, 2009).
Occasionally, dying patients with severe, uncontrollable pain also receive psy-
chosurgery. Still, even these cases raise important ethical issues, and psychosurgery
remains a highly controversial treatment (Mashour, Walker, & Martuza, 2005;
Steele
et al., 2007).
Biomedical Therapies
in Perspective
In some respects, no greater revolution has occurred in the fi eld of mental health
than biological approaches to treatment. As previously violent, uncontrollable patients
have been calmed by the use of drugs, mental hospitals have
been able to concentrate
more on actually helping patients and less on custodial functions. Similarly, patients
whose lives have been disrupted by depression or bipolar episodes have been able
to function normally, and other forms of drug therapy have also shown remarkable
results.
The use of biomedical therapy for everyday problems is rising. For example, one
survey of users of a college counseling service found that from 1989 to 2001, the
proportion of students receiving treatment who were taking medication for psycho-
logical disorders increased from 10% to 25% (Benton et al., 2003).
Furthermore, new forms of biomedical therapy are promising. For example, the
newest treatment possibility—which remains experimental at this point—is gene
therapy. As we discussed when considering
behavioral genetics, specifi c genes may
be introduced to particular regions of the brain. These genes then have the potential
to reverse or even prevent biochemical events that give rise to psychological disor-
ders (Sapolsky, 2003; Lymberis et al., 2004; Tuszynski, 2007).
Do'stlaringiz bilan baham: