Week 52/08 Dates 22/12/08 – 23/12/08 Weekly Planning Lists

APPEALS NOTIFIED:

Area	Area 1 - South East
Application Number	4628/08
Appeal Type	Written Evidence
Applicant	Con Creedon
Location	To rear of 127, 129 & 131 Tritonville Road, Sandymount, Dublin 4
Proposal	Planning permission & retention permission - The development will consist of the construction of 3no. two storey over basement terraced mews houses. The proposed development comprises of a 90sqm unit (mews 1), a 118sqm unit (mews 2) and a 110sqm unit (mews 3). Each house will provide 1no. bedroom and private individual gardens to the rear. 5 no. parking spaces (including 2no. spaces for 129 and 131 Tritonville Road) are proposed at basement level with access off Herbert Road via a car lift and turntable. The basement car parking area and access arrangement is previously permitted under reg. ref. no. 1717/07. Also proposed at basement level are individual home cinemas and storage areas. Landscaping, and all associated site development works are also proposed. Retention permission is also sought for the extended basement area (98sqm) to the rear of the permitted basement area (reg. ref. 1717/07).

Area	Area 1 - South East
Application Number	4636/08
Appeal Type	Written Evidence
Applicant	Conor Lineham
Location	58, Sandford Road, Ranelagh, Dublin 6
Proposal	Front vehicular access with metal gates (by increasing the existing pedestrian opening to 3.0 metres), an off street car parking space and ancillary site development works.

Area	Area 1 - South East
Application Number	4679/08
Appeal Type	Written Evidence
Applicant	Westbourne Partnership
Location	2, Lansdowne Gardens, Shelbourne Road, Ballsbridge, Dublin 4
Proposal	Planning permission for development on a site of c. 0.047 hectares. The application site is bounded generally to the north by no. 1 Lansdowne Gardens, to the west by Shelbourne Road, to the south by Crampton Avenue and to the east by the rear garden of no. 2 Lansdowne Gardens, (which is the subject of a concurrent planning application). The development will consist of works to the existing semi-detached dwelling house comprising of:- A) Demolition of the following:- (i) c. 15sqm gross floor area (GFA) of the existing habitable house which includes:- a) the single storey utility room to the rear of the property and b) part of the roof space including 2no. dormer windows at the rear of the house at 2nd floor level. (ii) Removal of parts of the rear elevation wall at ground and first floor level. (iii) Part of the existing wall at Crampton Avenue (c.24.3m in length). (iv) The existing boundary plinth wall and railings to Shelbourne Road (c. 9.6m in length) and (v) Other internal demolition works including the removal of an existing WC at ground floor; removal of the internal staircases: and removal of some internal partition walls. B) Construction of the following:- (i) A basement level of 197sqm which will accommodate a gym, multimedia room and study; (ii) The construction of a 2 storey extension to the rear of the property (77sqm) to comprise kitchen/dining and bedroom accommodation; and (iii) The provision of a new lead clad dormer window to the rear at second floor level. C) Ancillary works as follows:- (i) All ancillary internal and external restoration and alterations works to the dwelling; (ii) All associated site development, boundary and landscape treatment works, including the provision of 2no. garden terraces at Level -1 and a new boundary stone garden wall (with railings incorporated) to Crampton Avenue (of c.39.9 metres in length) and to Shelbourne Road (of c. 9.6 metres in length); and (iii) Provision of a new vehicular access to the site off Shelbourne Road to facilitate off-street car parking to the front of the dwelling. As a result of the proposed development, the GFA of the dwelling house will increase from c. 237sqm to c. 305sqm above ground plus basement level of c.197sqm.

Area	Area 1 - South East
Application Number	4680/08
Appeal Type	Written Evidence
Applicant	Brian & Rosa Stephens
Location__Leinster_Park,_Harolds_Cross_Road,_Dublin_6W__Proposal'>Location__37,_Windsor_Road,_Dublin_6__Proposal'>Location	52, Nutley Avenue, Donnybrook, Dublin 4
Proposal	The development will consist of alterations to the existing rear boundary wall adjoining Elm Park cul-de-sac including new pedestrian gate with brick arch, new railings on top of wall to replace existing timber trellising and a ramp to the gate in the garden at rear of existing house.

Area	Area 1 - South East
Application Number	4513/08
Appeal Type	Written Evidence
Applicant	James Donoghue
Location	16, Rathmines Road Lower, Dublin 6
Proposal	PROTECTED STRUCTURE - Works to the existing three storey over basement property, to include (a) Demolition of existing rear return and associated external stairs (b) internal alterations to existing layout at basement level (c) Provision of a new 4 storey over basement return structure to accommodate kitchen & dining space to the unit at basement level, utility & storage facility and external terrace with associated replacement steps at ground floor level and a one bedroom triplex unit to first, second and third floor levels and all associate site works. (D) Upgrading and landscaping of external space to the rear. (E) The retention & conservation and protection & repair of existing historical features throughout works.
	***Amendment to week 51/08***

Area	Area 1 - South East
Application Number	4535/08
Appeal Type	Written Evidence
Applicant	Mr Ben McArdle
Location	Rear of 120, Merrion Road, Ballsbridge, Dublin 4
Proposal	The development will consist of the construction of 2 no. two storey over basement four bedroom semi-detached mews dwellings, that will each include an internal terrace at first floor level and ground floor balcony to rear, plus rooflights, solar panels and sedum roof at roof level, with each dwelling being served by 1 no. car parking space (2 no. overall) to the rear. The development will also include the demolition of existing wall bounding the rear of the site to widen the existing mews laneway that will provide vehicular and pedestrian access to the dwellings via the mews lane off Shrewsbury Park as well as new boundary treatment; landscape works and ancillary site development and services works.
	***Amendment to week 51/08***

APPEALS DECISIONS:

Area	Area 1 - South East
Application Number	1971/08
Appeal Decision	GRANT PERMISSION
Appeal Decision Date	23-Dec-2008
Applicant	Mr Rutger Kortenhorst
Location	37, Windsor Road, Dublin 6
Proposal	PROTECTED STRUCTURE - The development will consist of the demolition of the existing 3 no. concrete retaining walls and concrete base and the construction of a new bicycle and bin store, with minor alterations to the existing steps, landscaping and all associated site works.

Area	Area 1 - South East
Application Number	2141/08
Appeal Decision	GRANT PERMISSION
Appeal Decision Date	18-Dec-2008
Applicant	Leinster Park Management Company Limited
Location	Leinster Park, Harolds Cross Road, Dublin 6W
Proposal	RETENTION - Retain electric entrance gates, previously given permission for a fixed period of time.
	***amendment to week 51/08***

Area	Area 1 - South East
Application Number	2963/08
Appeal Decision	APPEAL WITHDRAWN
Appeal Decision Date	19-Dec-2008
Applicant	The Andrew's Lane Consortium
Location	Andrew's Lane Theatre, St Andrew's Lane, Dublin 2
Proposal	Planning permission for development on our site, the former Andrew's Lane Theatre, 9-17 St Andrew's Lane, Dublin 2. The development will consist of the demolition of the existing two storey theatre and replacment with an eight storey over basement mixed use development of 3,966.4sqm consisting of a double basement level theatre (574.3sqm) accessed from St Andrew's Lane (West) and lower basement car store (18 car spaces) access from St Andrew's Lane (North), with ground floor retail unit (80sqm), restaurant and wine-bar use at ground floor and mezzanine level (418.5sqm), office use at first to fifth floor accessed from entrance foyer on St Andrew's Lane (North) and setback penthouse office suite at sixth floor level (total office accommodation 2,332.5sqm), roof level plant area with visual screening to include wind turbine and solar panels. .
	***amendment to week 51/08***

Area	Area 1 - South East
Application Number	6583/07
Appeal Decision	GRANT PERMISSION
Appeal Decision Date	18-Dec-2008
Applicant	Padholme
Location	Nos 1-11 at The Donnybrook Mall, Donnybrook Road, Dublin 4
Proposal	The development will consist of: The demolition of existing 2 storey mixed-use building of approx. 1,629sqm (units nos. 1-11), and redevelopment of site to provide a 4 storey over basement mixed-use development of approx. 4,492sqm GFA (overall height 15.85m, 27.625m OD) comprising of 6no. retail units (approx. 1,220sqm), 3no. office units (approx. 1,107sqm), 1no. medical centre unit (approx. 524sqm), 1no. restaurant/takeaway unit (approx. 173sqm), 1no. bank unit (approx. 221sqm), and 4no. 2 bedroom apartments ranging in size from 95sqm to 122sqm (set back at fourth storey level) with terraces at third floor level facing east onto Donnybrook Road (facing east and north for apartment no. 1; east and south for apartment no. 4) and screened and sheltered deck access at third floor level facing rear of Belmont Park. The units comprise the following areas: Unit 1 at 80sqm (ground floor); Unit 2 at 150sqm (ground floor 79sqm; basement 71sqm); Unit 3 (restaurant/takeaway) at 173sqm (ground floor 104sqm; basement 69sqm); Unit 4 at 67sqm (ground floor 32sqm; basement 35sqm); Unit 5 at 220sqm (ground floor); Unit 6 at 122sqm (ground floor); Unit 7 (bank unit) at 221sqm (ground floor 112sqm; first floor 109sqm) and anchor convenience retail unit of 581sqm (ground floor 270sqm and basement 311sqm); at first floor level, 1no. medical centre of 524sqm, independent office unit of 238sqm, and 109sqm first floor element of Unit 7; at second floor level, 2no. independent office units of 489sqm and 380sqm respectively; this application provides for landscaped area on first floor roof level facing rear of Belmont Park; and ESB substation at ground floor level; 15no. car parking spaces and 15no. bicycle parking spaces, plant and attenuation, refuse storage all at basement level; ancillary site development works; use of existing reconfigured and repositioned vehicular access/egress (by approx. 3m to south west), on Belmont Avenue, all on overall site of approx. 0.14hectares.
	***amendment to week 51/08***