The holy faith of reformed samaritanism

Will the Creator condemn us for following a false religion? 
Scripture tells the story of a great miracle experienced by a Pagan [Syrian] widow. As is written: «Then 
Elijah said to her, “Don’t be afraid; go and do as you have said. But first make me a small loaf from it and 
bring it out to me. Afterward, you may make some for yourself and your son”... So she [the Syrian widow] 
proceeded to do according to the word of Elijah. Then the woman, Elijah, and her household ate for many 
days. The flour jar did not become empty, and the oil jug did not run dry, according to the word of the Lord 
he had spoken through Elijah»- 1 Kings 17:13-14, & 15-16 (Christian Standard Bible). 
What merit did this pagan women have, for the God of Israel to look upon her with mercy? Well, her merit 
was that, though a follower of pagan idols, she had shown mercy to hungry Elijah, providing him with food 
and water. Thus, she too was worthy of being blessed with food and water. 
Likewise, Scripture relates the story of a Syrian [Pagan] general to whom God granted a miraculous 
deliverance from his incurable disease. As is written: “Then went he [Naaman] down, and dipped himself 
seven times in Jordan, according to the saying of the man of God: and his flesh came again like unto the flesh
of a little child, and he was clean”- 2 Kings 5:14, KJV. 
Why was this idol worshiper worthy of God's deliverance? He was worthy because, though pagan, he had 
been an instrument for the deliverance of his own people. As is written: “Now Naaman, captain of the host of
269

---

the king of Syria, was a great man... because by him the Lord had given deliverance unto Syria”- 2 Kings 
5:1, KJV. Thus, Divine justice demands that he who had delivered other people be himself also delivered. 
Notice how, in the previous examples, God granted mercy and deliverance to idol worshipers, even before 
they had abandoned their paganism! But, isn't it important to have the correct theology? To follow the right 
religion? What moral lesson is Scripture trying to convey with these stories? They are recorded in order to 
teach us that, in the eyes of God, doing good with our existing theology is far more important than having a 
good existing theology. 
Curiously, on this regard Jewish tradition seems to agree with Reformed Samaritanism, when it goes on to 
say: «Elijah [the prophet] said: “