particular female ones, were common
at that time across the Greek world,
but also show up regional variations
in poses and styles.
11
In 1976, Saul
Weinberg established a list of all the
stone Neolithic figurines he knew, a
list that has, to my knowledge, not
been updated.
12
Although some were
found all over the Greek world, from
Thessaly to Crete and the islands,
few of them are seated. Indeed, the
position with the legs crossed, or
seemingly crossed, is attested mainly
in the Cyclades (Saliagos, Naxos)
and possibly Attica, which would
tend to confirm that the Brussels
sculpture does indeed come from
the islands. Of the dozens of known
stone figurines, three are very close
to the Brussels sculpture not just
typologically, but also stylistically:
a statue found fortuitously on the
island of Naxos, at Sangri,
13
and two
in the Shelby White collection in New
York; for clarity’s sake, I will call the
bigger one “Shelby White no. 1”
14
and the smaller one “Shelby White
no. 2”.
15
The Brussels and Shelby
White no. 1 sculptures are close in
size (respectively 18.5 cm and 20.3
cm) whereas the one found on Naxos
is only about half their size (9.2 cm)
and the Shelby White no. 2 is 13 cm.
The general geometric shape, the
juxtaposition of a somewhat conical
head and neck on a rectangular
upper body set on a rounded heavy
lower body can all be compared.
The volume of the upper arms is
depicted in a very similar manner on
all examples.
16
The position of the
bent arms, with the fingers touching,
and the way the legs and toes are
sculpted, all match closely. On the
Shelby White no. 1 and Naxos pieces,
the head is separated from the neck,
which is not the case with the Brussels
and Shelby White no. 2 examples. The
buttocks are often more rounded than
on the Brussels example. The Shelby
White no. 1 statue also presents a
decorative pattern on the upper arms,
which is unique. A few other seated
female figures are less close in style
although their general appearance is
similar, such as a figurine in Oxford,
said to come from Patissia (Athens),
as well as the “Fat Lady” from
Saliagos. The lack of clear dating or
provenances for these pieces, and
the long period when they could have
been made (over 1,000 years), makes
it difficult to take these comparisons
much further.
17
The sculptures found in the Cyclades
were either accidental finds (Naxos)
or were not found in an informative
archaeological context (Saliagos).
18
Generally speaking, most figurines
across the Greek world were found
in settlements rather than in tombs,
although there are a few exceptions.
When accompanying material gives
some indication as to the use of the
spaces in which they were found, this
points towards food conservation
or processing (cooking) or towards
wool working (loom weights). As a
result, these objects may have been
associated with domestic economy
but we do not have any real indication
about how they were regarded or
used.
19
M.N.
1
Wood was probably also used although
no sculpture in this material has been
preserved.
2
See e.g. the examples from Saliagos.
3
See most recently on this important figure
of the antiques art market, Driessen 2016,
p. 122.
4
Hogarth 1927, pp. 56–60, pl. VIIa (front)
and IXc (back).
5
Michon 1929, p. 256 and fig. 6 who
specifies that he includes this piece
as Segredakis accepted to have it
photographed. The caption of the
photograph is as follows: “Idole primitive.
Appartient à M. Segredakis”.
6
Getz-Gentle 2011, pp. 10–11.
7
Ibid., p. 13.
8
Verhoogen 1930, pp. 23, 24, 26.
9
Oxford, Ashmolean Museum of Art
and Archaeology, inv. 1895, 166 (AE 148).
Hogarth 1927 indicates in the caption of
this piece that it comes from Amorgos.
Weinberg 1951, p. 122 gave the provenance
as Patissia (Athens), as is written on the
object. See also Weinberg 1976, p. 59 and
Thimme 1976, no. 5, p. 420.
10
Evans and Renfrew 1968, pp. 62–63.
11
For examples, see Marangou 1996b;
Orphanidi 1996; Papathanassopoulos
1996b and the section of the catalogue of
Papathanassopoulos 1996a titled “figurines
and models”, pp. 293–323.
12
Weinberg 1976, pp. 59–60; the figurine
which appears in the same catalogue
(Thimme 1976) as no. 4 is not in his list. See
already, for seated figurines, Weinberg 1951,
pp. 121–133.
13
First mentioned in
Do'stlaringiz bilan baham: |