Manuscript No: 20150261/ ojs 12130 Reviewer’s Name

SAUDI MEDICAL JOURNAL

Manuscript No: 20150261/ OJS 12130
Reviewer’s Name: DR TUNAU KARIMA
I have read the manuscript entitled: MenarcheAmongst Saudi Girls; Any Change in Secular Trend?

And recommended that it should be: Accepted without change

Accepted with minor changes

Reassessed after major revision

Reject

Accept as brief communication

See Comments
If the recommendation is to accept, please recommend a priority:
High Average Low



If priority is HIGH please give rank (1-10):


CONFIDENTIAL Comments to the Editor:
THANK YOU FOR THE OPPURTUNITY

REMARKS to Authors:

The article is an interesting one and it was well presented. .

Specific:

• 
  The title –appropriate .
  
• 
  Abstract : apprppriate
  
• 
  Introduction: well presented
  
• 
  Methodology: FAIRLY presented for the type of study.
  
• 
  Results : FAIRLY presented See manuscript
  
• 
  Discussion: well presented
  
• 
  References: good
  

Recommendation:

The authors should revise the manuscript in line with the above comments and re-submit for further consideration.

*Please let us know if you can review the revised manuscript:

Yes, I will review the revised manuscript
No. I will not review the revised manuscript