8
I P T F O R P T S D
3. We noticed that trauma shatters patients’ sense of safety about their
environment and about people in their environment.
Individuals with
PTSD suffer from affective distancing or numbing, and withdraw so-
cially. Unable to trust their feelings, they cannot “read” or trust their
environment. Numbed, they avoid or try to ignore painful negative
affects (anger, sadness, anxiety) that in fact serve as important signals
about interpersonal encounters. Without such input, patients were
“flying blind” and likely to be revictimized,
not knowing whom to
trust and whom to avoid. Hence we decided to focus the initial stage of
IPT treatment on
affective attunement.
We asked patients repeatedly
how they were feeling, what the name of the feeling was (“I’m upset,”
for example, is non- specific), whether it was a reasonable reaction to
the interpersonal encounter, and what it might tell them about that
encounter. In discussing current daily interactions— not past trau-
matic events— we tried to help patients gain
an emotional vocabulary
for their interactions, to see negative emotions not as dangerous but
as useful interpersonal signposts they could use to decode confusing
situations.
With Kathryn Bleiberg at Cornell, I wrote the first version of the treatment
manual that is the basis for this book. We somewhat arbitrarily set the length
of treatment at 14 weekly 50- minute sessions. As no one had tested IPT for
PTSD, we had no idea how long treatment ought to last.
Our initial open study (Bleiberg & Markowitz, 2005) treated 14
patients
with chronic PTSD. Therapists used much of the first half of treatment to re-
build emotional attunement in benumbed patients— this symptom is not typ-
ical of depression, but it is a hallmark of chronic PTSD. Then therapists applied
standard IPT maneuvers to patients’ difficulties with trust and expressing
emotions in daily relationships. Therapists avoided encouraging exposure
to trauma reminders. Patients with varied, but predominantly interpersonal
rather
than impersonal, traumas received 14 weekly IPT sessions. All but one
patient completed treatment.
At the end of treatment, 12 of 14 patients no longer met diagnostic crite-
ria for PTSD. CAPS (Blake et al., 1995; Weathers et al., 2001) scores fell from
67 (SD = 19) to 25 (SD = 17), a large within- group effect (d = 1.8), with im-
provement across PTSD symptom clusters. This drop in the CAPS score took
patients from severe PTSD to near- remission. Depressive symptoms,
anger re-
actions, and social functioning improved. As patients became more comfort-
able with their emotions and handling daily interpersonal encounters, they
exposed themselves to traumatic fear reminders without therapist encourage-
ment— a change necessary for PTSD remission. (See Table 1.2.)
Is Exposure Therapy Necessary to Treat PTSD?
9
Patients reported general interpersonal improvement on the Social
Adjustment Scale (Weissman & Bothwell, 1976) and other interpersonal
measures. Ten completed the Interpersonal Psychotherapy Outcome Scale
(IPOS; Markowitz et al., 2006), a self- report measure on which patients
score change in the interpersonal problem area which IPT focused on
during the treatment interval. On the IPOS, 1 = significant worsening in
the area, 2 = mild
worsening, 3 = no change, 4 = mild improvement, and
5 = significant improvement. All subjects reported some positive inter-
personal change (minimum score = 4), and mean improvement was 4.77
(SD = 0.34) out of a possible five. IPOS scores correlated with CAPS im-
provement: that is, how much patients improved in resolving their in-
terpersonal difficulties correlated with reduction in PTSD symptoms
(Markowitz et al., 2006).
Ten patients completed the Inventory of Interpersonal Problems (Horowitz
et al., 1988), a measure of interpersonal difficulties, and showed significant
improvement in total score (ES = 1.15;
Wilcoxon Signed Ranks Test,
p
= 0.005)
and on all subscales, particularly the Cold/ Distant (ES = 1.39, p = 0.008)
and Self- Sacrificing (ES = 1.38,
p
= 0.009) circumplex subscales. Compared
Table 1. 2.
Cornell Trial: Scores at Baseline and After 14 Weeks of IPT- PTSD
Do'stlaringiz bilan baham: