5. General Division - Criminal
PD 5.3
Supreme Court of Western Australia
Consolidated Practice Direction
12. VCCC conferences will ordinarily commence at 9.00 am and, unless
prior arrangements have been agreed, take no more than one hour (so
that counsel may depart for other jurisdictions). During a conference the
facilitator will seek to identify issues that might be resolved, and to
discuss generally with the parties the future conduct of the case.
13. The purpose of a VCCC conference
is to reach agreement, where
possible, in respect of any aspects of the criminal trial process. It may
include discussion about:
(a) the strength of the prosecution case;
(b) whether the current charge reflects the evidence in the prosecution
brief;
(c) the real matters in issue;
(d) whether agreement may be reached about matters which are not
in issue; and
(e) any matters relevant to case management.
14. To facilitate a meaningful discussion about
these issues the following
principles and rules apply to each conference:
(a) An accused's participation in the conference is not to be taken as
an indication of any intention to plead guilty.
(b) A person present at a conference may draw the attention of the
accused to options that are open to him or her, including the
option of a plea or pleas of guilty,
and the considerations that
should be taken into account in evaluating those options.
However the accused shall not otherwise be subjected to any
pressure (directly or indirectly) to plead guilty during the course
of or as a result of the conference.
(c) Any agreement by an accused, at the conference, to plead guilty to
a charge does not inhibit in any way his or her right to enter a plea
of not guilty should he or she change his or her mind after the
conference and before entering a plea. However in that event it
would be open to the prosecution to reconsider any other aspects
of any agreement reached at the conference.
5. General Division - Criminal
PD 5.3
Supreme Court of Western Australia
Consolidated Practice Direction
(d) The conference does not form part of the trial process. No record
of the proceedings will become part of any Court file.
(e) A report as to the outcome of the conference will be made by the
facilitator to the Judge in charge of the criminal list. Where the
objectives of the conference include case management, a case
management report will be made to the Judge in charge of the
criminal list. The report summarises the matters agreed.
(f)
Nothing an accused says during a conference or that is said on his
or her behalf during a conference may be used against him or her
in court in the criminal proceedings
to which the conference
relates or in any related criminal proceedings (other than in a trial
for a criminal offence which is allegedly committed during a
conference by a person present at the conference). Participation by
the prosecution is conditional upon it agreeing that nothing said
by an accused or any person on the accused's behalf at the
conference may be tendered in evidence at the accused's trial on
the charge or charges arising out of the matter the subject of the
conference.
(g) A party or lawyer present at the conference may use information
obtained in the course of a conference
to prepare their or their
client's, case for trial. This may include disclosing that information
to another person. If an accused person does not wish the
prosecution to know his or her defence or to investigate his or her
defence before trial, the accused and/or his or her lawyer should
ensure that it is not disclosed during the course of a conference.
(h) Whilst the court encourages frank discussions during a
conference, there is no obligation on a party to disclose privileged
or confidential information at a conference.