The Invisible Constitution in Comparative Perspective



Download 4,63 Mb.
Pdf ko'rish
bet278/366
Sana18.08.2021
Hajmi4,63 Mb.
#150519
1   ...   274   275   276   277   278   279   280   281   ...   366
Bog'liq
The Invisible Constitution in Comparative Perspective by Rosalind Dixon (editor), Adrienne Stone (editor) (z-lib.org)

The Evolution of Natural Law in Ireland 

439


The courts, as they were and are bound to, recognised the Constitution as 

the fundamental law of the State to which the organs of the State were sub-

ject and at no stage recognised the provisions of the natural law as superior 

to the Constitution.

24

And so, ‘with these brief but unequivocal statements, it seemed that the influ-



ence of natural law on Irish constitutional jurisprudence had been stopped in 

its tracks’.

25

 The Court’s reasoning has been criticised as illogical,



26

 as disin-

genuous in its treatment of the authorities,

27

 or as having outright ‘abandoned 



precedent by using positive law’.

28

 Whatever one thinks about the historical 



accuracy of the Courts’ account, the decision marked a clear step away from 

the religious rhetoric and moral reasoning that characterised the earlier juris-

prudence. The accepted view of the Abortion Information Bill reference is 

thus that it heralded ‘the death of natural law’ in Ireland. This has also been 

linked in the literature with an asserted abandonment of the unenumerated 

rights doctrine.

29

Perhaps of particular relevance to the broader questions addressed in this 



book is the view of these developments as a rejection of an illegitimate ‘lack 

of objectivity in recognition of rights’ by allowing judges to make decisions 

by reference to unspecified values. This account holds that the ‘none of the 

techniques used to identify these implied constitutional rights seemed to give 

any objective guide to what rights were contained within the Constitution’, 

instead involving a ‘breadth of . . . discretion [which] eclipsed the discretion 

ordinary afforded in interpreting ambiguous text’.

30

 This is a view that appears 



to take direct issue with both the possibility and appropriateness of invisibility 

in constitutional adjudication.

As the next section contends, however, this ‘death of the natural law’ narra-

tive may be misconceived. The proposition that the Irish courts have eschewed 

the invisible (be that natural law or unenumerated rights) in favour of an 

24 


[1995] 1 IR 1, 42–3.

25 


A. Kavanagh, ‘Natural Law, Christian Values and the Ideal of Justice’ (2012) 48 (2) The Irish 

Jurist 71, 91.

26 


G. Whyte, ‘Natural Law and the Constitution’ (1996) 14 Irish Law Times 8.

27 


Twomey, Supra note 2.

28 


Kristen E. Carder, ‘Liberalizing Abortion in Ireland: In re Article 26 and the Passage of the 

Regulation of Information (Services Outside the State for the Termination of Pregnancies) 

Bill’ (1996) 3 Tulsa Journal of Comparative and International Law 253, 254.

29 


Oran Doyle, ‘Legal Positivism, Natural Law and the Constitution’ (2009) 31 Dublin University 

Law Journal 206.

30 


David Kenny, ‘Recent Developments in the Right of the Person in Article 40.3: Fleming v 

Ireland and the Spectre of Unenumerated Rights’ (2013) 36 Dublin University Law Journal, 322.




440 

Eoin Carolan

objective (and visible) approach to constitutional reasoning is contradicted by 

subsequent developments, by the original natural law jurisprudence properly 

construed and, arguably, by the nature of constitutional adjudication itself.

15.3.  The Death of Natural Law: A Report Greatly Exaggerated?

In rejecting the claim advanced on behalf of the unborn in the Abortion 

Information Bill reference, the Supreme Court has commonly been por-

trayed as having rejected the constitutional status of natural law itself. This 

may, however, represent an overreaction to the outcome of that reference. As 

Gerry Whyte has pointed out, the proposition on which the Court was asked 

to adjudicate in this reference was a stark one which went far beyond its pre-

vious jurisprudence.

[Here t]he Supreme Court was asked to take one variant of natural law theory 

beyond its previous role as a source of implied rights to its logical, anti-major-

itarian extreme so as to empower an unelected, unrepresentative judiciary to 

set aside decisions of the people made by way of referendum.

31

Indeed, it may be questioned whether this proposal was, from a legal perspec-



tive, the logical corollary of the Constitution’s endorsement of natural law.  

The fact that the natural law was undoubtedly invisible in the sense of 

being non-explicit did not thereby mean that it was invisible in the non- or 

extra-constitutional sense of standing outside or above the legal regime. Even 

O’Hanlon’s argument drew a distinction between natural law as a source of 

constitutional value and natural law as the constitutionally authoritative value, 

although it seems to regard the two as logically intertwined. In seeking to 

understand the precise implications of the Abortion Information Bill ruling, it 

is important to carefully consider what the courts’ earlier references to natural 

law may or may not have meant.




Download 4,63 Mb.

Do'stlaringiz bilan baham:
1   ...   274   275   276   277   278   279   280   281   ...   366




Ma'lumotlar bazasi mualliflik huquqi bilan himoyalangan ©hozir.org 2024
ma'muriyatiga murojaat qiling

kiriting | ro'yxatdan o'tish
    Bosh sahifa
юртда тантана
Боғда битган
Бугун юртда
Эшитганлар жилманглар
Эшитмадим деманглар
битган бодомлар
Yangiariq tumani
qitish marakazi
Raqamli texnologiyalar
ilishida muhokamadan
tasdiqqa tavsiya
tavsiya etilgan
iqtisodiyot kafedrasi
steiermarkischen landesregierung
asarlaringizni yuboring
o'zingizning asarlaringizni
Iltimos faqat
faqat o'zingizning
steierm rkischen
landesregierung fachabteilung
rkischen landesregierung
hamshira loyihasi
loyihasi mavsum
faolyatining oqibatlari
asosiy adabiyotlar
fakulteti ahborot
ahborot havfsizligi
havfsizligi kafedrasi
fanidan bo’yicha
fakulteti iqtisodiyot
boshqaruv fakulteti
chiqarishda boshqaruv
ishlab chiqarishda
iqtisodiyot fakultet
multiservis tarmoqlari
fanidan asosiy
Uzbek fanidan
mavzulari potok
asosidagi multiservis
'aliyyil a'ziym
billahil 'aliyyil
illaa billahil
quvvata illaa
falah' deganida
Kompyuter savodxonligi
bo’yicha mustaqil
'alal falah'
Hayya 'alal
'alas soloh
Hayya 'alas
mavsum boyicha


yuklab olish