The Invisible Constitution in Comparative Perspective



Download 4,63 Mb.
Pdf ko'rish
bet186/366
Sana18.08.2021
Hajmi4,63 Mb.
#150519
1   ...   182   183   184   185   186   187   188   189   ...   366
Bog'liq
The Invisible Constitution in Comparative Perspective by Rosalind Dixon (editor), Adrienne Stone (editor) (z-lib.org)

Iddo Porat

sense, not the “real” thing. Texts of constitutions are the result of political 

compromises, and of the works of humans who are influenced by the con-

tingencies of their time and culture, and the pressures of the hour. They may 

even be the work of ignorant or racist people. Constitutional texts are thus 

imperfect things, and are prone to be so. They can also be incomplete or filled 

with caveats. And they are temporal and can be revoked or changed. The only 

“real” thing is the Idea of a constitution, or the Idea of a constitutional right, 

as these Ideas, or ideal Forms, are absolved from the imperfections of the  

text, transcend national borders and historical circumstances and are, in 

essence, objective and eternal.

The crucial element in this interpretative theory is the role assigned to the 

constitutional judge. The judge owes her allegiance to the objective, abstract, 

and pure Idea of the constitution or of the right, and not to the imperfect 

contingent manifestation of it in the text. Weinrib writes: “the judicial func-

tion is to evaluate whether the state’s encroachment on the right violates the 

constitutional principles of equal citizenship and inherent human dignity [the 

objective right], of which the specific guarantees [subjective right] are impor-

tant but not exhaustive exemplars.”

59

 The judge should apply to the case the 



ideal Form and not the flawed text, or at least he or she should strive to do so, 

and should get direction and guidance directly from that ideal Form.

Another important feature of Weinrib’s quote, especially if put in the con-

text of my suggested analogy to the Israeli case, is that this Form includes not 

only constitutional rights, but also some institutional aspects such as judicial 

review and the ability to invalidate laws. All of them comprise the “objective 

value order” which “transcend the history, cultural heritage and social mores 

of any particular nation state.”

Note finally that the objective value order also has a substantive focal point, 

or center – it is “equal citizenship and inherent human dignity.” For Weinrib, 

so it seems, these two principles are the essence of constitutionalism, and from 

them both the constitutional institutions and the different manifestations of 

constitutional rights are derived. We might view them as a higher order ideal 

Form. The text is only a manifestation of the ideal Form of rights, and these 

rights, in their turn, are only manifestations of the ideal Form of the supreme 

or overarching right, which is “equal citizenship and human dignity.” The 

influence of German Constitutional jurisprudence and theory is evident here 

as well, as it similarly has an overarching constitutional value – human dig-

nity. As mentioned earlier Germany is also the birthplace of such concepts as 

59 


Ibid.

, at 93–4.




 

The Platonic Conception of the Israeli Constitution 

289


“objective value order,”

60

 and in German jurisprudence the idea of the text as 



only an approximation of the true right is explicitly endorsed.

61

 This, although 



there are some important special characteristics of the German version of the 

Platonic conception that distinguish it, for example, from the Israeli version - 

in particular the fact that it is accompanied by legal formalism.

62

9.3.4.  The Platonic Conception and the Israeli Constitutional Revolution

All of this fits very well with Barak’s project of bridging the gap between the 

ideal constitution and the imperfect text of the Basic Laws. For Barak and 

for those Justices that joined his opinion in Mizrahi and in subsequent cases, 

their allegiance is to the Idea of a constitution and not to its imperfect mani-

festation in Israeli law, and they therefore strive to move Israeli law as close as 

they can to that Idea. This ideal Form, as in Weinrib’s account, includes both 

the institution of judicial review itself and the content of the protected bill 

of rights. Since the ideal Form of a constitution includes judicial review, the 

Court can imply judicial review, even if it is not clear by the text or (as in the 

case of the old Basic Laws), has no relation to the text.

63

 Second, the limited 



and imperfect list of rights in the Basic Laws is but a shadow of the true Idea 

or Form of a bill of rights that the Justices should try and achieve through 

interpretation. The filling in of the missing rights, despite its contradiction to 

60 


The term was coined in the Luth case of 1958; Lüth, Bundesverfassungsgericht [BVerfG] [Fed-

eral Constitutional Court] January 15, 1958, 7 Entscheidungen des Bundesverfassungsgerichts 

[BverfGE] 198 (F.R.G.).

61 


Jacco Bomhoff, Balancing and Constitutional Rights: The Origins and Meanings of Postwar 


Download 4,63 Mb.

Do'stlaringiz bilan baham:
1   ...   182   183   184   185   186   187   188   189   ...   366




Ma'lumotlar bazasi mualliflik huquqi bilan himoyalangan ©hozir.org 2024
ma'muriyatiga murojaat qiling

kiriting | ro'yxatdan o'tish
    Bosh sahifa
юртда тантана
Боғда битган
Бугун юртда
Эшитганлар жилманглар
Эшитмадим деманглар
битган бодомлар
Yangiariq tumani
qitish marakazi
Raqamli texnologiyalar
ilishida muhokamadan
tasdiqqa tavsiya
tavsiya etilgan
iqtisodiyot kafedrasi
steiermarkischen landesregierung
asarlaringizni yuboring
o'zingizning asarlaringizni
Iltimos faqat
faqat o'zingizning
steierm rkischen
landesregierung fachabteilung
rkischen landesregierung
hamshira loyihasi
loyihasi mavsum
faolyatining oqibatlari
asosiy adabiyotlar
fakulteti ahborot
ahborot havfsizligi
havfsizligi kafedrasi
fanidan bo’yicha
fakulteti iqtisodiyot
boshqaruv fakulteti
chiqarishda boshqaruv
ishlab chiqarishda
iqtisodiyot fakultet
multiservis tarmoqlari
fanidan asosiy
Uzbek fanidan
mavzulari potok
asosidagi multiservis
'aliyyil a'ziym
billahil 'aliyyil
illaa billahil
quvvata illaa
falah' deganida
Kompyuter savodxonligi
bo’yicha mustaqil
'alal falah'
Hayya 'alal
'alas soloh
Hayya 'alas
mavsum boyicha


yuklab olish