particularly given their contrasting intentions, and neither should it be
assumed that more interesting fairy tale allusions are only to be found
in independent art-house fare. This assumption seems implicit in many
critical discussions, in Zipes’ distinction between ‘conventional’ and
‘experimental’ films (2011), or Greenhill and Matrix’s claim that the
fairy tale films discussed in their collection range from ‘entertaining and
escapist’ endeavours to ‘deeply political’ fare (2010: 8). Although they
note that fairy tale motifs can be found in ‘Hollywood, international,
and independent productions’ (8), there is a tendency to privilege the
latter categories while negatively conflating Hollywood with escapism
(in direct contrast to the criteria used for the online top 50 mentioned
earlier, which explicitly allots points for such features!). Are we all sim-
ply looking for different things in the fairy tale film? And is academic
derision, largely on the grounds of popularity, necessarily correct?
A central aim in this work is to counter some questionable assumptions,
asserting that we should not reject, out of hand, fairy tale-inspired films
produced by a major studio, intended for mass appeal, or which are ‘feel-
good’ in tone, but should appraise each film on its own merits, challeng-
ing what is regarded as politically progressive or unorthodox. Fidelity to
the source is beside the point – as Warner puts it, ‘shape-shifting is one of
14
Fairy Tale and Film
fairy-tale’s dominant and characteristic wonders’ (1995: xvi) – and claims
about a radical folkloric past are too patently idealised to consider here,
yet neither are irreverent or tongue-in-cheek versions necessarily deemed
alternative
– in the true sense of the word. Instead, the films selected for
discussion have been chosen because they highlight the multiple generic
features of fairy tale tropes and exemplify how certain themes remain
recognisable in film, albeit frequently altered to reflect changing times.
This includes rom-coms that give ‘Cinderella’ a modern makeover in
which finding a prince is secondary among the heroine’s aspirations;
comedies that use magical transformations to turn male protagonists
into more appealing partners; crime dramas that revise some interesting
moral lessons of earlier tales – combining the appeal of seeing under-
dogs triumph with salutary warnings about the potential cost of avarice;
thrillers that rewrite the Gothic template of ‘Bluebeard’ yet significantly
make heroines responsible for saving themselves; and horrors that affirm
profound dangers in the family home – while supernatural interventions
additionally seek to restore a sense of hope. Familiar tropes are thus
discerned among some very contemporary narratives in order to make
clear how diverse the fairy tale’s influence on film has been – aiming to
contribute another voice to the growing critical interest in this subject.
Beyond demonising Disney, or applauding artier twists on the fairy tale
for their supposed ability to ‘disenchant’ us, a more considered approach
asks that we evaluate every example in terms of what it has taken from
older sources, what is added, and what it has to tell us about who we are
today and what we want from life.
In seeking to explain the similarity between tales found around the
world, folklorists have tended to promote two different explanations.
Psychoanalytic accounts argue that tales are essentially symbolic,
encapsulating inner drives and conflicts that are innate, unchanging
and universal – which is why the same types of stories have been told
through the ages. An alternative explanation is the historic-geographic
approach, which contends that tales have travelled with us around the
globe, migrating and mutating over time. The similarity between certain
stories may offer a means of reassurance, suggesting that, despite our
differences, we share mutual interests and aspirations, yet the appeal of
forging connections (with both one another and our forebears) should
not come at the expense of recognising interesting points of difference
also, in terms of not only regional variations, but the impact of a chang-
ing social milieu. Recent research on ‘Red Riding Hood’ – attempting
to plot the tale’s global transition – received considerable attention in
the press, affirming a continued fascination in these tales, their origins
Do'stlaringiz bilan baham: |